Blog

Estate planning is a crucial process for everyone, but it becomes particularly complex for Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) who own assets in multiple countries. One of the most critical decisions in estate planning for NRIs is whether to draft separate wills for assets in different jurisdictions or have a single comprehensive will covering all assets.

This blog provides a detailed analysis of this issue, examining legal considerations, tax implications, advantages, challenges, and best practices for NRIs when managing their global assets through estate planning.

Understanding Estate Planning for NRIs

Estate planning involves arranging the management and distribution of an individual’s assets after their demise. For NRIs and Persons of Indian Origin (PIOs), estate planning must account for diverse legal frameworks in multiple countries. The key elements of estate planning include:

1. Drafting wills

2. Appointing executors

3. Managing inheritance tax implications

4. Setting up trusts (if required)

5. Coordinating estate distribution under different jurisdictions

Given the variations in succession laws, taxation policies, and probate procedures, NRIs often struggle with deciding whether a single will or separate wills is the better option.

Legal Frameworks Governing NRI Wills

1. Indian Legal Perspective on NRI Wills

NRIs can create a will under Indian succession laws for their Indian assets. The Indian Succession Act, 1925, governs the execution of wills in India, and it allows:

1. NRIs to draft separate wills exclusively for their assets in India.

2. Foreign wills to be executed in India if they comply with Indian legal standards.

3. Avoidance of inheritance tax, since India does not impose an estate duty.

2. International Legal Frameworks

Many NRIs own assets in countries like the USA, Canada, the UK, UAE, and Australia, where inheritance laws differ. The Hague Convention on Testamentary Dispositions (2005) recognizes wills made in other countries, provided they meet the laws of that jurisdiction.

However, some countries have strict inheritance laws:

• United Arab Emirates (UAE): Sharia law applies unless a registered will is in place.

• United States & UK: Inheritance tax applies to estates beyond a certain threshold.

• European Countries: Many countries have forced heirship laws, which dictate how assets must be distributed.

Why NRIs Should Consider Separate Wills for Different Countries

1. Clearer Distribution of Assets

Having separate wills ensures that assets are distributed according to the laws of the specific country where they are located. This prevents conflicts and provides clarity for beneficiaries.

2. Efficient Probate Process

Probate (legal authentication of a will) differs across jurisdictions. A single will may delay the probate process in different countries, while separate wills ensure that each jurisdiction follows its own probate procedure swiftly.

3. Avoidance of Legal Conflicts

Each country has its own succession laws. A single global will may lead to:

1. Conflicts over which country’s laws should apply.

2. Invalidation of certain will provisions.

3. Legal hurdles in enforcing foreign wills.

4. Tax Advantages

1. India has no inheritance tax, but countries like the UK (40%) and the USA (up to 40%) impose estate taxes.

2. Having separate wills can help beneficiaries minimize double taxation.

Challenges of Having Separate Wills

1. Risk of Contradictions Between Wills

If not drafted carefully, multiple wills could contradict each other, leading to confusion and disputes.

2. Increased Complexity and Cost

1. Multiple wills mean hiring lawyers in different jurisdictions, increasing legal fees.

2. More paperwork and additional costs for translations, notarizations, and registrations.

3. Registration and Execution Issues

Each country has different legal requirements for will registration and execution. NRIs must ensure:

1. Each will complies with local legal formalities.

2. Executors understand cross-border legalities.

Composite Will: An Alternative Option for NRIs

A composite will covers assets across multiple countries within a single document. While it simplifies estate planning, its effectiveness depends on:

1. Recognition under multiple legal systems.

2. Avoiding contradictions with local inheritance laws.

3. Efficient probate execution across borders.

Best Practices for NRIs When Drafting Wills

1. Consult Legal Experts in Multiple Jurisdictions

NRIs should consult estate planning professionals in each country where they own assets to ensure that their wills comply with local laws.

2. Ensure Each Will References Only the Relevant Assets

To avoid conflicts, each will should explicitly state that it applies only to assets located in that specific country.

3. Appoint Executors Familiar with Local Laws

Having local executors ensures smooth estate administration in each country.

4. Keep Wills Updated

Regular updates are essential, especially when acquiring new properties or in case of legal changes in a jurisdiction.

5. Ensure Digital and Physical Accessibility of Wills

Make sure your family and executors know where the wills are stored, whether digitally or in safe deposit boxes.

Conclusion

For NRIs, estate planning is a complex but essential process. While a single global will might seem convenient, separate wills for different countries can provide better clarity, efficiency, and tax benefits. However, multiple wills must be carefully drafted to avoid contradictions and ensure smooth execution.

Key Takeaways:

• Separate wills streamline probate and prevent legal hurdles.

• A composite will is an alternative but requires careful legal drafting.

• Consulting legal experts in each jurisdiction ensures compliance and protection of assets.

• Regular updates to wills are crucial for effective estate management.

For NRIs, careful estate planning can secure assets, protect beneficiaries, and avoid unnecessary legal complications. Taking proactive steps today can ensure peace of mind and a seamless transfer of wealth across generations.

For personalized legal guidance on NRI estate planning, consult a qualified estate lawyer in India and the countries where you hold assets. Proper planning now can prevent future disputes and legal challenges!

Inheritance tax, often referred to as estate duty or death tax, is a financial obligation imposed on the transfer of property and assets from a deceased individual to their beneficiaries. While many countries levy inheritance tax, India currently does not. However, discussions regarding its reimplementation have resurfaced. This blog explores the inheritance tax concept, its historical background, tax implications on inherited property, and methods to optimize taxation while inheriting assets.

Understanding Inheritance Tax

Inheritance tax is a levy imposed on the assets of a deceased person before they are transferred to legal heirs. In many countries, beneficiaries must pay taxes on inherited wealth. However, in India, no such tax exists, as estate duty was abolished in 1985 due to high tax rates and administrative inefficiencies.

Historical Background of Inheritance Tax in India

Estate duty in India was introduced in 1953 to curb wealth accumulation. However, the tax rates reached as high as 85% for larger estates, making its execution problematic. As a result, the government abolished inheritance tax in 1985, allowing assets to pass on to heirs without direct taxation.

Despite its abolition, the government periodically revisits the idea of reintroducing inheritance tax to ensure equitable wealth distribution. Thus, understanding the tax implications of inheriting and subsequently selling property remains crucial for legal heirs.

Taxation on Inherited Property in India

Although inheritance tax does not exist in India, other tax obligations arise upon inheriting property, such as income tax and capital gains tax when the property is sold.

1. Income Tax on Rent from Inherited Property

If a beneficiary inherits a property that generates rental income, they must declare this income under the head "Income from House Property" in their tax return and pay applicable income tax.

For example, if a deceased parent owned a commercial property generating Rs. 70,000 in rent per month, the legal heir inheriting it must report this rental income and pay income tax per their tax slab.

2. Capital Gains Tax on Sale of Inherited Property

Legal heirs are not liable for taxes at the time of inheritance but must pay capital gains tax if they decide to sell the inherited property. The taxation is determined based on the holding period, including the duration the deceased owned the property.

Short-Term Capital Gains (STCG)

If the inherited property is sold within 24 months from the original acquisition date, the profits are taxed as per the individual's income tax slab under STCG.

Long-Term Capital Gains (LTCG)

If the inherited property is sold after 24 months, it is taxed under LTCG, with a 20% tax rate plus indexation benefits.

Example:

1. Mr. Ashish inherited a property in 2019, originally purchased by his father in 1997 for Rs. 40,000.

2. If Mr. Ashish sells it in 2023 for Rs. 5,00,000, the LTCG applies since the property was held for more than 24 months.

3. He can benefit from indexation, reducing taxable capital gains and lowering tax liability.

How to Save Capital Gains Tax on Inherited Property

1. Section 54EC Bonds

Legal heirs can invest the capital gains from property sales in specified bonds within six months to claim exemption under Section 54EC. Eligible bonds include:

1. National Highway Authority of India (NHAI)

2. Indian Railways Finance Corporation Limited (IRFC)

3. Power Finance Corporation Ltd (PFC)

4. Rural Electrification Corporation Ltd (RECL)

The maximum investment limit is Rs. 50 lakh per financial year.

2. Section 54 Exemption (Reinvestment in Residential Property)

Heirs can reinvest sale proceeds into purchasing or constructing a new residential property to claim LTCG exemption under Section 54.

1. The new property must be purchased within two years before or three years after the sale of the inherited property.

2. Up to two properties can be purchased with a maximum LTCG exemption of Rs. 2 crore.

3. Gifting to Family Members

In India, gifts to specific relatives such as spouses, children, or parents are tax-free. Transferring property before sale to a lower-income family member could reduce tax liability.

4. HUF (Hindu Undivided Family) Tax Benefits

If a property is transferred to an HUF, tax planning can be optimized as HUFs enjoy separate tax exemptions and slabs, reducing tax liabilities.

Calculation of Inheritance Tax (Hypothetical Scenario)

If India were to reintroduce inheritance tax, it would likely be calculated as follows:

Example:

1. Mr. Ramesh inherits a property worth Rs. 10 crores.

2. Assuming an inheritance tax rate of 10% on wealth exceeding Rs. 5 crores,

   • Taxable inheritance = Rs. 10 crores - Rs. 5 crores = Rs. 5 crores

   • Inheritance tax payable = 10% of Rs. 5 crores = Rs. 50 lakhs

Since inheritance tax does not exist in India, no such liability applies, but similar laws exist in countries like the USA, UK, and Japan.

Methods of Inheritance in India

Inheritance of assets occurs through different legal structures, such as:

1. Will of Succession

A legally executed Will ensures a smooth transfer of assets to intended beneficiaries.

2. Inheritance by Nomination

Assets such as bank deposits, insurance policies, and mutual funds pass to the nominated individual upon the owner’s demise.

3. Inheritance by Joint Ownership

Assets jointly owned by individuals automatically transfer to the surviving owner(s).

Conclusion

While inheritance tax does not exist in India, beneficiaries must understand income tax and capital gains tax implications on inherited property. Proper tax planning through Section 54 exemptions, investment in bonds, and legal restructuring can help minimize tax burdens.

If the government reinstates inheritance tax in the future, legal heirs may need to plan their assets efficiently to avoid substantial tax liabilities.

Secure your inheritance today by drafting a well-structured Will! Seek expert legal assistance to ensure a hassle-free property transfer to your loved ones.